Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

Say it with a Rose…

Homepage Forums Photo Critique Catch All Macro and Close-ups Say it with a Rose…

  • This topic is empty.

Say it with a Rose…

  • Mikeanywhere
    Participant
    jb7
    Participant

    nice shot, and detail, and lighting-
    Toning is maybe a little strong,
    or would be in a print,
    but prints and the web are two completely different media,
    I suppose.

    I’d have a slight issue with the aspect ratio,
    being nearly square, but not,
    but it is a painterly ratio,
    and does suit the subject.

    one other thing is the junction ofthe petals at the bottom of the frame,
    it does tend to lead straight out of the picture, with no route back-

    Many others would disagree, of course-

    j

    GrahamB
    Participant

    Nice shot but I’m not a fan of the toning,
    it seems a little un-natural for a natural subjuect if that makes sense.
    I agree with J on the crop at the bottom of the shot. Perhaps coming back out
    a little would help eliminate the fall of

    Mikeanywhere
    Participant

    Thank you for the feedback guys!!

    Rob
    Member

    I like this Mike, notwithstanding the contentious crossing
    of petals at the bottom of the frame. Beautiful texture to those
    petals – almost vellum. The toning? I don’t mind it too much,
    though I might be tempted to desaturate slightly to give a more
    delicate look to the petals.

    Rob.

    Noely F
    Participant

    I like it, maybe fade the outside to black leaving the centre in sharp focus?

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.