Same here, the first one is pretty good. The tone is perfect and the composition is much more dynamic with the lines of the tree and the guitar crossing each other and the guy filling up the space nicely. The only thing I would change is his shoes… it might be just me, but I think a pair of black shoes would look better with the suit.
On the second the composition, the sharpness on the face and the expression on his face don’t work really well.