Like the second, not as strong as the first though, the handrails on the right side pier are a bit lost a slightly
higher point of view would have isolated them.
The first one is a cracker, it really is. It’s very refreshing. I could see that printed on canvas hanging on the wall of a nice classy coffee shop or pub. v Very very good.
BTW: did you clone something out just under the red sky, in the sea? There’s a darker patch of sea surrounded by brighter reflecting water.
Love the first picture as its so pin sharp. I think there is a picture there in the second with the crack in the slipway taking your eye into the water, its just as is, its a little too busy a composition.