this is an interesting one and poses a bit of a dilemna…..without the poster, there’s not much to it, so therefore is it a good photo because its a photo of a good photo, or is it just a good photo. i guess its a both…..the B&W suits it well, adds to it for sure, the lighting seems very good….the unfinished plastering above the poster adds to the subject of the poster….I would say overall very good effort (and better than I would have done :-)). Perhaps a few people in it, commuters or otherwise, might have made it an even better image.