Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

Simple Life

Homepage Forums Photo Critique Landscape Simple Life

  • This topic is empty.

Simple Life

  • LoGill
    Participant

    With all the great weather its great to be getting out and about in the evenings with the camera :0 and we’re spoiled with all the amazing sunsets these days.. I took this from the South Bull Pier a week, (of course, as usual … I had the wrong lens :shock: so i couldn’t get closer)

    Anyway these two lads were bringing in their catch , chatting away about their day (I could hear them from the pier, good Dub accents :D carry for miles) and it seemed like a nice simple life.. or so I thought anyway… Any comments/ recommendations?

    Lorraine

    Moya
    Participant

    No pic showing for me :(

    LoGill
    Participant

    how about now ??

    Lorraine

    Moya
    Participant

    Nope! Very strange……

    LoGill
    Participant

    Not so strange :oops: – left the file with a capital letter – hopefully it should be visible now….. :shock:

    Moya
    Participant

    Ah there it is! Great sunset shot….I like the boat as a focal point….makes this interesting.

    DaveC
    Participant

    Great example of why the horizon line doesn’t always have to be on the thirds.
    Composition rules are there to be broken.

    LoGill
    Participant

    Thanks Dave – I had a bit of a debate about the horizon at home before I posted it :wink: and I did toy with straightening it for a while … but I prefered the natural perspective looking along the pier at an angle in the direction of the boat so i left it .. I was sure everyone would be telling me that its crooked and I should fix it :lol:

    They probably will nw :D

    Lorraine

    ciaran
    Participant

    Its crooked and should be fixed :D

    Dave was commenting on how the horizon is on the center (well would be if it was straight :lol: ) It does break the normal rules of composition by not being on a third.. but I like it.

    LoGill
    Participant

    :oops: Well ok then – sorry dave… :lol: But I still say its the angle of the shot … Its not crooked :P

    Lorraine

    Moya
    Participant

    What about someone like me who actually chooses to have things crooked?!?! And that’s not just in photos!! I don’t always like straight horizons. I dunno….my humble opinion…I like it just the way it is!

    jlang
    Participant

    I don’t think the shore line should be horizontal in the shot or at least if you were standing there and measured the angle, I don’t think it would be because the land is arcing away from you.

    Apart from the horizon, I love the colour and the boat hidden in the foreground.

    DaveC
    Participant

    The horizon line of water should always be dead straight because in reality that’s the gravity is.

    That’s exactly what I meant Ciaran, about the thirds.

    nolonger
    Participant

    I was going to comment on the horizon… but then I noticed that the *land* itself seems fairly straight, which throws me off with the water being not quite straight.

    LoGill
    Participant

    I even used a tripod for this and lined up the horizon :) Oh the self doubt ….

    Picture this … :)

    Standing on the pier at South Bull – looking accross Dublin bay to North Bull (land) and then looking left along the line of land curving back to the Docks in the direction of passing boat .. .. Am I mad – Should this be straight ? … I still think its the angle of the perspective but the gravity comment is throwing me :D – its hard to argue with the laws of physics :shock:

    Lorraine

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.