Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

I hope this is the right section

Homepage Forums Photo Critique People I hope this is the right section

  • This topic is empty.

I hope this is the right section

  • Jack_Ryan
    Participant

    got some old pic’s re-edited recently

    Critique is definately welcome

    and of course the lovely Ali (Altho I feel guilty claiming this as my picture)

    rymus
    Member

    *edited because my opinion isnt required here… I’ll remember that in future*

    gerardk
    Participant

    Those are very impressive – particularly the first and the last ones in my opinion. Can I ask – did you do an unsharp mask and touch of colour to the models lips in the first one ?

    Valentia
    Member

    I know they are all posed but the second one shows. I like 1 & 3.

    ellude
    Participant

    Hey Jack! The first is great! Love the angle. Not mad about the second and hate the third (nothing to do with Ali, it’s just overexposed)

    nolonger
    Participant

    I like the first and last. The middle one feels a bit… “Honey, why do I always have to pose for photos when we’re on vacation??” to me.

    DaveC
    Participant

    Absolutely love the first one, helps that she’s gorgeous.

    ciaran
    Participant

    The first portrait of LJ is superb John. Very nice indeed :)

    I don’t care very much for either of the other two.

    Jack_Ryan
    Participant

    ciaran wrote:

    The first portrait of LJ is superb John. Very nice indeed :)

    I don’t care very much for either of the other two.

    you always were a sucker for a head shot ;)

    ciaran
    Participant

    Jack_Ryan wrote:

    you always were a sucker for a head shot ;)

    Yup, but thats not the reason for me not liking the other two. The shot of Ali is grossly overexposed and then pushed again in Photoshop to give it a deliberate artistic feel – I don’t think it works. The other shot of LJ technically looks ok in terms of exposure, sharpness etc but it’s completely uninspiring and for a model shot, I don’t think its flattering to her. Where as shot no.1, forgetting the fact that it’s a head shot, is original, well composed and more importantly makes LJ look quite attractive.

    Roberto
    Member

    I like the first one.
    I don’t think that the face in the second one suit to the clothing. I think that this type of face will be good with gothic punk clothing.

    ciaran
    Participant

    Roberto wrote:

    I like the first one.
    I don’t think that the face in the second one suit to the clothing. I think that this type of face will be good with gothic punk clothing.

    The face in the second one is the same face as the first one :) And people say cameras dont lie!!

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.