My attention is taken with #1 as there’s more going on in the image, with colour and detail, there’s the little bits of colour along the pier and the stones in the foreground etc all make up a nice image
Pat
Silly question Sean! It’s #1 – the other 2 look mucky in comparison. Nice clear shot and it is unusually helped by a large stoney foreground which I wouldn’t have expected if you had said you were going to post it.