Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

Carlow Harvest

Homepage Forums Photo Critique Landscape Carlow Harvest

  • This topic is empty.

Carlow Harvest

  • Padraig
    Participant
    shutterbug
    Participant

    Nice sky and lovely warm colours Padraig, though I think the front bale
    looks a little overpowering, if a little more space were given in front
    of it, it might have been better?

    Padraig
    Participant

    Thanks Jenny. Don’t do many landscapes. Was trying out my new wide angle. Thanks for commenting.

    RASMITH32
    Member

    I like it. nice sharpness all the way through and composition is good (for me). The eye runs nicely top the mountain in the background. Is the sky just a little dark?, Is this teh original sky or is it a nuber of exposures merged?

    Padraig
    Participant

    Thanks RAS. It is the original sky but HDR processed. I tried not to over do it.Here is a non HDR version

    code187
    Participant

    Nice shot,I prefer the non HDR version.

    Padraig
    Participant

    Thanks Austin. I’m inclined to agree. I never quite know what I’m doing when it comes to HDR, just messing about with sliders!

    miki g
    Participant

    Hi Padraig.
    The non-HDR version looks good, but I prefer the warmth of the bales in the HDR version. I would be happy with either of them. Well done

    RASMITH32
    Member

    Maybe just a contrast boost to the sky or copy the layer and set it to an overlay blending mode with a capacity of around 50% and paint in with a layer mask for the sky only. The HDR does bring out nice detail in the straw

    flynny
    Participant

    Maybe a little more contrast in the sky,
    It looks a tad flat,
    Otherwise its a fine shot.

    markclehane
    Participant

    Hi Padraig. As has been mentioned, that sky is more of an issue in my opinion than the bales. I’m guessing you didn’t use a polariser? That should have been enough to bring up a good sky I’d say. Still something I like about it though. Have a similar one myself but your composition has more impact.

    Padraig
    Participant

    Thanks everyone for all the comments. I’ll take another look at the sky as suggested. I actually did use a polarizer, but it was a cheap ebay one and I expected better results. I must invest in a quality one. As I said earlier I don’t do much landscape so i really appreciate the feedback. :D

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.