Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

Cottage in Winter

Homepage Forums Photo Critique Landscape Cottage in Winter

  • This topic is empty.

Cottage in Winter

  • sirvad
    Member

    Old Cottage near naul co. Dublin, taking last winter.

    C/C welcome

    steelydan
    Participant

    Nice Image , I like it very much. The Tree been central does not take away from the image as the cottage balances it out. One small thing is , i would get rid of the telephone pole and wire (bottom right)

    sirvad
    Member

    thanks John, didnt know if getting rid of the pole and wire would improve it. I kinda like a bit of roughness in it but will delete to have another look. cheers

    carrigman
    Participant

    Nice image but I too would get rid of the pole and wires. I also would have liked a bit more foreground. The base of the cottage is too near the bottom of the frame for my liking.

    bingbongbiddley
    Participant

    This is nice indeed. I agree with the above comment about the cottage being too close to the bottom.

    Why would you want to get rid of the telegraph pole? I disagree with that completely. It’s fine in there, it’s part of the image. Why, oh why are people obsessed with removing electricity supply from their pictures.

    aoluain
    Participant

    bingbongbiddley wrote:

    This is nice indeed. I agree with the above comment about the cottage being too close to the bottom.

    Why would you want to get rid of the telegraph pole? I disagree with that completely. It’s fine in there, it’s part of the image. Why, oh why are people obsessed with removing electricity supply from their pictures.

    Agree with BBB, the pole suits the scene, however there are times
    where poles and wires can be a negative feature in a image but not so here.

    johnnymc
    Participant

    Hi Sirvad,

    I love the way the gable of the cottage seems to be falling in/collapsing. Lovely image,

    John

    sirvad
    Member

    thank you all for your time, comments and advice, really appreciate it.

    cathald
    Participant

    Yeah a nice image
    Agree with above re a bit more foreground but its nice as is
    Poles dont bother me either

    Cathal

    sirvad
    Member

    Thanks for your comments Cathald

    nice photo nothing wrong with the pole. love where the tree is. makes you wonder which came first

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.