Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

First attempt

Homepage Forums Photo Critique Catch All First attempt

  • This topic is empty.

First attempt

  • Charles ONeill
    Participant

    This is my first attempt at this type of photograph. I would welcome comments and opinions.

    Derelict by C.O’N, on Flickr

    5faythe
    Participant

    Hi Charles,

    It struck me on first viewing that this was a photograph that might
    look better in colour.

    The vehicle on the trailer, which I assume is the subject, looks a little
    lost here surrounded as it is with similar tones.
    Assuming the machine and the trailer are not green I think they might be
    more prominent against the green foliage.

    The composition feels a little static which may be because the subject
    is quite centrally placed in the frame.

    The darkened edges do help to concentrate the attention of the viewer towards
    the main subject.

    I think you may have found a good subject and while this is a good photograph there
    may be a better one to be had.

    Only an opinion of course.

    Cheers,

    John.

    Charles ONeill
    Participant

    Thanks John for your very well considered critique. It’s much appreciated..

    np72
    Participant

    Was this shot posted before? I remember seeing before, and am sure I posted something. Maybe its just deja vu :lol:

    Charles ONeill
    Participant

    np72 wrote:

    Was this shot posted before? I remember seeing before, and am sure I posted something. Maybe its just deja vu :lol:

    first post..

    np72
    Participant

    If its your first post, then I have seen something almost exactly the same, taken at the same spot, as I seem to remember asking where it was taken, because I had a feeling I might have known where it was, and it turned out the be the spot I thought it was, not too far from Howth Castle :D

    Charles ONeill
    Participant

    Hi Nigel, Now I’m baffled too, because I do remember a comment like that too, and thought that maybe it was on Flickr, but no… You’re correct about the location. maybe I included in another set afterwards ??????

    np72
    Participant

    The original post here was 24th of June, who knows, may have been flickr, but I definately remember it, because I had been in the vacinity of Howth Castle the weekend before or after I saw the shot, and had passed the spot where the shot was taken months before you took it.

    Anyway, its a good shot, was it a black and white or colour converted? Next time I’m up that way, I must go looking and see if its become any more overgrown.

    shutterbug
    Participant

    Charles O’Neill wrote:

    Hi Nigel, Now I’m baffled too, because I do remember a comment like that too, and thought that maybe it was on Flickr, but no… You’re correct about the location. maybe I included in another set afterwards ??????

    :lol: It is included in a set you posted titled “Dereliction”

    Charles ONeill
    Participant

    Got in now. Thanks

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.