Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

Glendalough

Homepage Forums Photo Critique Landscape Glendalough

  • This topic is empty.

Glendalough

  • sharnahws
    Member

    So Glad to be back had such a dram having my camera stolen from Ebay, but have a new one now (not as good) but some decent shots…..

    The sky in the first ones not original!





    Pixelle
    Member

    1]

    The sky in the first ones not original!

    And the water? Some funny goings on in the reflections of the twigs left of the trunk.

    3] and 4] need a bit more headroom, I think. Good sky in 3]

    5] The presence of a person is a bit superfluous perhaps, [unless of course his name is Kevin.]

    The pics are too-oo close for comfort, more space makes for easier viewing.

    sharnahws
    Member

    Thanks for the comments will take them all on board, the first one with the fake sky i tried to reflect in the water but obiously didnt do the water properly,
    Thanks again
    Sharon

    lousy
    Participant

    Hi Sharon.
    They all seem a little tight to me, however my fav would be
    #4, but still too tight and if there were more room all round it would
    be even better.
    Cheers.

    Pat.

    PS sorry to hear about your camera, I’d say you were rightly peed off.
    best of luck with the new one

    Mr.H
    Participant

    I like the last one… very quirky. I’d crop at the reflection line though… just to mess with the viewers mind a bit more.

    Gary

    Deebo
    Participant

    Good shots and as Pix says, some breathing room and these would be much better. 3 and 4 have great potential for mono.
    As Gary says the last one could be altered to make it more interesting, took me a few glances as is to work it out
    Happy snapping/
    Dee

    no 1 and the last one! great great images. No 1 needs a horizon update, last one is so confusing. When you crop the top a bit the effect becomes stronger!

    Very creative pic. Had to look at it for a while!

    Pixelle
    Member

    Well now just goes to show!!
    I barely clanced at the last one before jumping to conclusions. Having looked at it properly it’s much more interesting. Well done for spotting the possibilities.

    oh you fooled me with the sky :D i didn’t see that.
    why does nobody adapt images after image suggestions? too lazy or are the critics wrong or unimportant.???

    sharnahws
    Member

    Thanks for all the comments guys, have taken them all on board and will be back soon with the adjusted images…….
    Sharon

    sharnahws
    Member

    Well I`m back with this image, Do you think its any better, or is it veering slightly in the other direction?
    Thanks again for critiques……

    now it is a great image. based on your copied sky…it has to be mirrowed in the sea reflexion…vertical ( :. all together nice image although i am not a big fan of copied skies. Cheers M

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.