Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

Knockadoon Pier

Homepage Forums Photo Critique Landscape Knockadoon Pier

  • This topic is empty.

Knockadoon Pier

  • flynny
    Participant

    Something a bit different for me.I’ve seen shots like this on here before,so I’d like to get a bit of feedback on these.
    I know that there are people at the end of the pier in the second shot,but there wasn’t a lot I could do about that. :x

    sirvad
    Member

    Hi Paul, if im honest with ya, i wouldnt be mad into them. I know from your other images that you are a great photographer so maybe its just i was expecting more out of them :) out of the 2 i wud go for the 2nd and i actually think its the 2 people at the end that give it the edge. but ya know what?, id could see these hanging on a wall in a nice frame in a Hotel or Bar. Good to see people come out of their comfort zones so well done and keep up the good work.

    voicu
    Participant

    i like both of them and i think that people at the end should be seen as a good thing rather than a bad one, without them the photo will be a small bit boring, a small bit like “seen this before”

    westcoast
    Member

    I like the second one, the people make it work. well done :)

    5faythe
    Participant

    Hi Paul,

    I tend to like this type of photograph and it isn’t that easy to do.

    #1 for some reason dosen’t quite hit the spot.
    Maybe it’s the composition.
    All the elements seem to be there and it’s not a bad image.
    I think there may be too much sky and I think maybe the signpost dosen’t fit.

    #2 is definitely a contender IMO.
    I like the composition.
    I think the people at the end of the pier add greatly to the picture.

    Well done,

    John.

    flynny
    Participant

    Hi Folks ,
    Thanks a million for the replies,
    As I said at the start ,this is something that I wouldn’t normally try,
    Having said that ,I am reasonably pleased with the results.
    I’m well aware that this wouldn’t be everyone cup of tea,
    The missus had a look at them the other day and reckoned that they were rubbish :lol:
    Ah well back to rocks and water I guess.
    Thanks again for the replies.

    voicu
    Participant

    no offence but i think it’s time to change the missus :lol:

    Deebo
    Participant

    Second shot for me Paul, the people add interest and scale.
    First one needs a little rotation I think.
    Dee

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.