Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

Magheramore Beach – Long Exposure

Homepage Forums Photo Critique Landscape Magheramore Beach – Long Exposure

  • This topic is empty.

Magheramore Beach – Long Exposure

  • brendancullen
    Participant

    Located about 8 miles south of Wicklow Town. Very popular with wind surfers when wind is right.
    Taken 1pm 11/9/2010

    Canon EOS 7D & Sigma 10-20mm 10mm
    F/18
    ISO 100
    410 second exposure
    B+W 3.0 1000x filter (10 stopper) & a Hoya ND8 Filter giving me a 13 stop light reduction.
    Some levels & curves in Photoshop
    All C&C read & Appreciated.

    Green Meanie
    Participant

    Hi Brendan,

    I just got a 10 stopper this week myself so I was very interested in the post when I saw the title.

    I love the effect a long exposure has with the clouds but I think the dirty brown looking water botton left is a lttle distracting and I think I had a similar problem when I was experimenting during the week. If it’s sandy or there’s a lot of seaweed in shallow water this seems to happen. Ideally (I think) you should be looking for a stoney sea bed with clear water for the best results with these type of shots.

    This is of course all qualified by my 3 days experience so far :roll:

    Thanks,
    John.

    LWheeler
    Participant

    Hi,

    I like this photograph – but am thinking that it might look better in black and white – have you tried doing a conversion to see ?

    Lawrence

    http://www.lawrencewheelerphotography.com

    brendancullen
    Participant

    Thanks John & Lawrence.

    I did go specifically today to get a ‘minimalist B&W’ shot – but didn’t think there was enough tonal range when i got home. The scale here is a little deceptive – as this little rocky feature is about 8’x4′. I shouldn’t have been out taking photos in harsh sunlight at 1pm anyway – but i got a nice tan in the process waiting for the images. The clouds & wind direction were perfect for coastal ‘long exposures’ today so i had to go.

    The composition is perhaps passable. If i had reframed it – i would have had some headland and other rocks included – so this was as best i could do given the scene, sun position and desired outcome. 7pm would have been much better.

    Here is the conversion for your honest opinion.

    bren

    Mark N
    Participant

    Brendan

    I much prefer the colour version. I would be very happy to have taken this shot.

    Mark

    LWheeler
    Participant

    Hi Brendan,

    I can see what you are saying about the tonal range in the Black and White version, however that being said I still like it, and prefer it to the colour version.

    Lawrence

    http://www.lawrencewheelerphotography.com

    Definitively stronger in color for my taste.

    RASMITH32
    Member

    Yes colour for me also, much better

    David Qualter
    Participant

    The colour version is much better. I think it’s a really nice shot. Very well taken.

    DougL
    Participant

    Hey Brendan,

    I may be in the minority here, but I’m not entirely convinced by the composition. I’m just not sure about the rock in the centre of the frame. I think it might work with a bit of negative space to balance it out.

    -Doug

    Klarens
    Participant

    Yes Yes… colour version is much better! Well done!

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.