Homepage › Forums › Photo Critique › People › Real Men Smoke Players!!
- This topic is empty.
Real Men Smoke Players!!
-
AliParticipant
This is absolutely fab Robbie :) grain, conversion, everything. Super work :D
LoGillParticipantExpresbro wrote:
Ta Lorraine. Do you think the three windows are okay? Was gonna tone them down a lot as in Danny’s edit…but I don’t want to completely change the shot if possible?
Hmmm . I don’t find them distracting .. maybe a llittle dodge, just to see whow it looks .. I think the biggest issue for me was the girl .. ;) So its all good :D
L
ExpresbroParticipantThanks Ali …. :D :D ..again..coming from you..that makes my day :D
Lorraine…I have toned the windows down a fair bit…so I think this will be the final edit…hopefully now get a 12×8 print done and give Pat a copy..see what he thinks…
Cheers everyone 8)
David_SParticipantabsolutely fantastic image
your edits are equally good, but must say there is something about the original that i love :D
d
GrahamBParticipantI will go with David_s on this one.
I do like the edits but i think the original still holds its own.Good work Robbie. :D
paperdollParticipantThats a super shot Robbie, I’ll bet you’re chuffed with this one, and so you should be :)
ExpresbroParticipantSure am Tara, but now I’m split over which version is best… :lol: Good complaint of course. There’s also the original colour version which I like too.
Thanks again for all the comments folks ..mucho appreciated :D :D
SodafarlMemberRobbie
I would stick wiith the original an absolute cracking shot IMHO.
SodaDenverDollParticipantExpresbroParticipantOn a slightly funny side note. It has occured to..or rather was pointed out to me..that some of our younger members and overseas members might not understand the reference to “Players” in the title (hehehe!! Sharon). “Players” in this case refers to an old brand of non tipped cigarettes that would have been popular in the 40’s and 50’s, but which would not be very common among smokers today (thankfully probably). The subject of the shot Pat was indeed smoking Players when I took the picture.
The US equivalent would probably be Camels.
Now yis all know…. :wink:
DenverDollParticipantso..in that case..I retract my former estimation…and I prefer the final edit. :wink:
ExpresbroParticipantDenverDollParticipant:shock: I am speechless. For once. :shock:
ok..actually I am biting my tongue…really hard :lol:
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.