- This topic is empty.
Twilight lake A or B?
-
I like the submerges rocks in the foreground of the first photo, just something about them, I can’t quite put my finger on it.
I would prefer #1 meself.
But your really asking for a personal opinion here
and I think you are going to get a 50/50 result!I like the cool look about it and the simplicity
is good, soothing.I like them both but if I was buying one it would be A. I liek the fact that there is a bit more to see in the shot which makes it slightly more interesting than B. Like them both though.
for me definitely #2. In #1 the rock is more the subject of the picture while in #2 it’s function is the lead-in foreground of the landscape. That’s the reason I end up in #2 at the island while in #1 the island is just an extra element… both pictures are for me the difference between detail-in-landscape (#1) and landscape-with-foreground (#2). It’s a pity of the beautiful rocks under the surface but removal of them improves the composition for me
The first one for me – the rock detail in the water is fabulous and adds to the shot.
The balance is a little off in both, in my opinion. I’d trim about a quarter of the underwater rocks from the bottom of the first one, to have the foreground rock and the horizon roughly equidistant from their respective ends of the frame.
Same with the sky in the second.
Excellent images, though.
Peter
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
