Homepage › Forums › Photo Critique › Street and Documentary › Waterford Regional Hospital Street Protest.
- This topic is empty.
Waterford Regional Hospital Street Protest.
-
AnonymousParticipant
The images are not here for critique but to highlight the cuts being made not just in Waterford but nationally.
IsabellaParticipantyep, sickening. cuts to all but the deserving.
you seem to not be fond of shadow detail, sacrificing all in favor of the ‘never blow out a highlight’ rule. in my view its a choice not an obligation.
AnonymousParticipantI don’t think I understand Isabella. Are you suggesting that the images are too dark?
IsabellaParticipantto say that they are too dark would be too strong. its more of an observation than a criticism. there is nothing ‘wrong’ with your exposure
i would probably dodge many of the shadow areas a wee bit so they don’t merge so much. the second last for instance – a multi headed monster creature as all the blacks become one shape. the highlights and mid tones are beautifully exposed.
brownieParticipantIsabella, John 17 said they weren’t up for critique and there you go…one comment and straight in with critique ???????
Great effort John at showing the whole flavour of the day…well done.
Noel.
AnonymousParticipantThanks Noel, lets hope that it wasn’t in vain. This region has suffered enough.
tommybMemberThe images are not here for critique but to highlight the cuts being made not just in Waterford but nationally.
Isabella, John 17 said they weren’t up for critique and there you go…one comment and straight in with critique ???????
Not here for critique in a photo critique forum? I don’t get it, I come for the photography, not to mull over a gloomy economy.
What the obsession that people have with multiple exclamation marks and questions marks? Can someone explain that to me in a photo that’s not for critique?
brownieParticipantObviously the “gloomy economy” doesn’t effect you then tommyb or else you wouldn’t answer here with a stupid remark like that…by the way…you took your time to have a go…2 months to come up with an answer like that…well done !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Noel.
tommybMemberI didn’t realize you had to read and respond threads to when they were posted, that might explain the delay.
But don’t worry if you don’t get that, it’s only a trivial thing :)
Oh, and by the way- these comments aren’t for critique.
brownieParticipantstreetshooterMemberC’mon folks, can we get back to Street or Documentary shots in this thread please?
ss
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.