Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

Which would you prefer

Homepage Forums Photo Critique Landscape Which would you prefer

  • This topic is empty.

Which would you prefer

  • RASMITH32
    Member

    I played around with this one after noticing issues with the first draft . Appreciate if you could confirm your preference 1, 2, or 3?
    Key differences are , less dodging / burning on the skys of 2 & 3. Removal of the hedge on the far right of the bridge in 2 & 3 and a cross process hue on the water to give it a little lift on 3.

    Dont get too hung up on the border, just trying to visualise it mounted.

    1

    2

    3

    Anonymous
    Participant

    I prefer image 1 but in image 2 there is a little difference to the water as opposed to image 1 that I think looks better.

    This doesn’t exactly answer your question but I hope it helps in someway!

    Isabella
    Participant

    sky from 1, water from 3, absence of hedge

    jodal1975
    Participant

    1 less the hedge

    RASMITH32
    Member

    Thanks all, a leaning towards 1 in general, which incidently is the problem image . Look closely at the top left & right of the sky and you can see streaks, To remove I have to reprocess and I havent been able to produce 1 again :-)

    JMac-2006
    Participant

    RAS looks great and can imagine it printed large. Probably go for 2 and to be really picky remove the white airplane trail in the blue part of sky. If you keep looking for faults you’ll find them but most people would never notice – I say print it! :)

    Pete27
    Member

    Prefer image 2. Overall I feel it just works better. The hedge definitely is a distraction in 1 and I dont think the water works in 3.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.