Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only

White Head

Homepage Forums Photo Critique Landscape White Head

  • This topic is empty.

White Head

  • neilmcshane
    Participant

    Taken on a weekend trip to Ballycastle last year.
    C&C welcome.

    Regards Neil

    StevenHanna
    Member

    Really love the composition in this image, with a great sky and I think the whole subject looks well in B & W.
    The only thing I might suggest is to add a little more contrast, and maybe a little bit of dodging & burning in the sky – that sky has so much potential and could look even more dramatic (if that was the look you were after).

    Really good image Neil.

    Steven

    GrahamB
    Participant

    I love the dramatic sky in this shot. I would loke to see it in colour.
    If there was even a hint of a red sky it might look great if really boost
    the colour up. It give a little more impact to an already dramtic sky.

    aj
    Participant

    the b/w conversion works very very well gr8 compo and exposure aj

    andy mcinroy
    Participant

    I was down here by Kenbane castle a few weeks ago. Did you blatantly disregard the no-entry signs like I did?

    This is an excellent shot. Looks like you must have been there on a summer morning to get the light hitting the cliff. Makes them look even more impressive.

    I do feel that the shot could do with a little bit of rotation though.

    Andy

    Banjo
    Participant

    Great shot in B&W, menacing clouds.

    SteveD
    Participant

    Nice shot Neil, very dramatic. I do think it needs a little bit more work in terms of overall contrast though.

    amcinroy wrote:

    I was down here by Kenbane castle a few weeks ago. Did you blatantly disregard the no-entry signs like I did?

    Did you both know that area is haunted!!? Never go there alone! :lol:

    Rob
    Member

    amcinroy wrote:

    I do feel that the shot could do with a little bit of rotation though.

    Andy

    My thoughts too. Apart from that,
    marvellous capture Neil.

    Rob.

    jb7
    Participant

    Hello Neil-

    I’d agree with the consensus regarding the rotation-
    I know you usually filter in camera,
    but I’m wondering if there has been some post process darkening of the sky in this case-
    the tops of the cliffs do seem to have a distinct dark edge to them,
    while the sky seems to lighten at that junction-

    I must admit to not being entirely taken with this one,
    maybe its the wedge shaped composition,
    and the lack of definition in the cliff face-
    and maybe its because the sky does appear to be one grade harder than the rest of the picture.

    I don’t know the orientation,
    or the time of day,
    but you can see a lit cliff face in the far distance,
    and the modeling does help-

    sorry for not being more positive-

    j

    blacktopjunkie
    Participant

    I really like this. Perfect amount of sea and cliff for me

    joe_elway
    Participant

    Think I agree with Steven. I’d like to see it with more contrast.

    neilmcshane
    Participant

    Thanks for all the comments guy’s.

    Andy
    What signs and locked gates :D

    This shot was taken in the afternoon around 4’o clock on our way back to the hotel after a long day around the Antrim coast.
    It was a long walk down so I was not going to turned back by a sign.
    Took a lot of shots of the castle and surrounds.
    I agree with all the comments about the contrast.
    Here is were i have a problem with posting images.
    This is a 150Kb compressed jpeg file of a 60MB 16bit PSD file. So alot of the detail is going to be lost in the file you see on your computer screens.
    You should see the finished print. It looks different to the screen. Again I have 4 computer screens and it looks different on the all except one to the print.
    In the last club competition it got 9/10 and all the judge said was he might crop a bit of the bottem.

    Once again thanks for your comments.

    Roberto
    Member

    I was looking this shot more time and had same feeling as JB but could not put in words…..
    I like the composition and in print must look fab.

    andy mcinroy
    Participant

    neilmcshane wrote:

    In the last club competition it got 9/10 and all the judge said was he might crop a bit of the bottem.

    To be honest Neil, I think that at your proficient level of photography, you should probably be ignoring camera club judges. It’s always good to get broad feedback from as many people as possible and this forum is excellent for that, but your own critical self appraisal should probably be starting to have greater influence.

    Andy

    Rob
    Member

    amcinroy wrote:

    To be honest Neil, I think that at your proficient level of photography, you should probably be ignoring camera club judges. It’s always good to get broad feedback from as many people as possible…

    Andy

    Hear hear. Well said Andy.

    Rob.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 20 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.