I’d go for the one without the polariser. True, the polarier has brought out a lot more depth in the foreground but I think that detracts from the pumphouse as the focal point of the image. In the first image the building sits comfortably as the focus where as in the second one I find it isn’t as strong. I might also consider shaving a little off the bottom and left of the first image to help it a little further. I’d be curious to see it in a different light, the dull overcast sky isn’t doing the scene any favours but with a nice splash of dawn or dusk colours (orange building, blue sky + water) this composition might come into its own.
I’m in Dundrum and also own a 400D, I won’t be around this weekend, but if you’re still looking for some pointers next week I’d be happy to help where I can.
//Cian
EDIT: Oops, just noticed I have an extra 0 in mine. Oh, well, offer still stands.
I’ve had a similar experience, I have a 400D and a couple of months back bought an old EOS 5, it’s 15 years old (I think) and it’s fantastic! It’s far nicer to use than the 400D, bigger view finder, nicer control layout and does 5 fps.
I was strolling around Dundrum shopping center with my cmaera over my shoulder, I had no intention of taking photos because I fully expected to have a security guard kick me out. Interestingly, a security guard came up to me anyway and said that if I wanted to take photos I had to check in with the customer service desk. I was really surprised that they “confronted” me anyway but even more surprised that they allowed photography.
As for the shot, I agree that it would have been nice to see more floor.
Ah sure when someone throws down the gauntlet and all that . . .
It’s a nice shot too, I love the subtlety of the sky, it’s smoothness contrastred with the texture in the water. I would be tempted to try to tone down the red in the water, bring back just a little of the blue, or maybe just to make the lighter points of the water a bit more neutral.
I guess you mean the piece of land that appears to be sticking out over the water?
I can think of 4 options in increasing likelyhood:
1) atmospheric diffraction, like a mirage
2) it’s a tree line with sparse trunks and dense foliage
3) a not quite perfect attempt at cloning
4) it’s a beach, lighting post processing and compression made the sand look the same colour as the mountains.
There’s no difference between a green screen and a blue screen, it’s just a case of choosing a colour to give contrast between the subject and the background for easy masking, hell you could probably use an orange screen depending on the subject. I’m not sure what you mean by
I wasn’t aware that this could be done on digital
, I pressume you mean you didn’t realise this could be done on digital without photo-editing software, in which case I completely agree. Of course if the backdrop was only very lightly blue a little white balance and exposure compensation tomfoolery could make it look pretty white but that would look pretty obvious. I wonder though if this is a misunderstanding, the photographer not answering the question the client was asking but the one he thought the client was asking, some critical detail lost in the retelling. My money is on the photographer meaning “it’s still the same background, I just desaturated it”.
Before reading this I could never really visualise what people meant when they said one lens had better bokeh than another. The first shot of the out of focus highlights is really good and lower down there’s a shot of a playground, both demonstrate the differences in bokeh.
I guess you’ve provided a relativly clear warning that you retain ownership of the images but you haven’t stopped people from downloading your shots and using them without permission.
I now want people to contact me before downloading my images , i.e. take ownership of my own files.
I think the best way to do this is to create a group with yourself as admin, restrict uploads to yourself and restrict viewing to members of the group. That way you have a list of people who can access your shots and can remove people from the list at any time. It’s actually not that much work to manage once you get it set up, the only thing is that people will have to ask your permission before even seeing the shots.
Compositionally great, the only thing I could think of to improve it would be a darker background to make yer man stand out a bit more. Either way it is really nice and the simplicity really works.