It seems I can’t move the topic myself, so I’ll let it hang here unless some moderator would want to move it to its proper place. I’ll know better next time.
1. There is a source of light to the left.
2. Don’t like the composition
3. Looks like a bright electric lamp used in making films
4. Can’t decide what is the main subject. The moon and the stones fight it out.
5. I’d say it’s perfect. Captures the mood and such. The stones somehow look like people around the campfire which helps the viewer to relate to the scene….