Fourth option for me also. The darker colours seem to draw your eyes to them more, so it appears the stronger picture.
And after tossing a coin, I voted for B to be tonemapped. Really hard to tell as they both don’t really look that natural… Great pic though, love the ‘moving’ water!
Thanks a million to both of you for the replies! Must say, I like the sound of that canon one – though maybe the A570 as that has image stableized zoom… must discuss with my other half!
And yes, I have been called mad, but I don’t see what’s wrong with furthering her interest and I’m never really happy when she uses our eos 350d or 20d (even when mounted on a tripod and we’re not further than a foot away, I get nervous of her accidentally knocking them over!)